Extortion in the name of tax is taxtortion. That’s what I challenged when Bangladesh government imposed VAT on every new mobile conection last year. Last Thursday the High Court division of Bangladesh Supreme Court has declared it illegal. Read the details in this link http://www.thedailystar.net/2006/08/25/d60825013922.htm
4 Comments
Divakar Goswami
Abu-da, that is a great achievement indeed! Congratulations. Not often does a private citizen take on the might of the state and win, especially in our part of the world.
Donald Gaminitillake
In Sri Lanka it is other way around
All phones do charge VAT
They issue VAT Invoice on billing system only
But on prepaid system we are unable to obtain a VAT INVOICE.
None of the telephone companies issue a VAT invoice even if you write and request.
All these compaines never acknowledge the VAT payments on prepaid system
They do collect VAT from the users. Then why cant they issue a VAT invoice for VAT payers on prepaid system. Even inland revenue do have a blind eye on this issue.
May be VAT Dinos are around!!!!
Donald Gaminitillake
Colombo
Sandhya Herath
Donald,
Do not blame the phone companies. It is the government that stipulates that no business enterprise should indicate VAT amount separately in their invoices to the END CUSTOMER.
Even the post paid customers do not get an invoice showing the VAT they pay.
I am not against imposing a tax on telecom usage, but that should be done in a methodical manner and keeping in mind that it is not just the Colombo 7 elite who uses mobile phones.
When a robber was asked why he always robs banks only pat came the reply “That is where money is”.
Our fiscal policy makers too are like that. They tax from where money is. Whether it is fair or not is secondary.
According to the prevailing rules if you telecast a dubbed 30 min foreign teledrama you have to pay Rs. 90,000 as tax, while if you telecast the same darned thing without dubbing, you have to pay much less.
You are forgiven for thinking it is the legendary king Kekille who imposed these taxes.
Donald Gaminitillake
Quote
VAT amount separately in their invoices to the END CUSTOMER
Unquote
They do have to indicate the VAT ammount to the VAT registered payer.
This is a mandotary rule.
When a VAT registered person write and request a VAT invoice they have to issue a proper VAT invoice. This is not done on prepaid system.
Quote
post paid customers do not get an invoice showing the VAT they pay.
unquote
If you are a VAT registerd person you can get a VAT invoice for Direct billing.
VAT is shown only for VAT registered persons.
“”MY question is misunderstod by you.””
IF A VAT registered person request a VAT invoice form a VAT registered institute who collect VAT unconditionally this institute has to issue a VAT invoice. None of the Telephone compnies issue a VAT invoice for VAT registered person for prepaid services. This is an illegal act.
Donald Gaminitillake
Colombo
Supreme Court recommends elimination of ‘public commotion’ clause in Telecom Bill, in line with LIRNEasia Chair’s recommendations
The Supreme Court of Sri Lanka recently ruled that several sections of the proposed Telecommunications Amendment Bill are inconsistent with the country’s Constitution. This decision comes after significant opposition and criticism from experts, including LIRNEasia Chair Prof.
LIRNEasia CEO Helani Galpaya speaks on disinformation and AI in the Global South at DW Global Media Forum
The implications of Artificial Intelligence (AI) extend beyond mere technological advancement. There is no doubt that while the Global North is gaining most of the benefits of AI, the Global South faces significant problems, such as biased language models.
Supreme Court cites LIRNEasia’s insights in Telecom Bill Determination
The Supreme Court last week determined that some sections of the Telecommunications Amendment Bill are inconsistent with the Constitution of Sri Lanka. The determination included a citation of the insights provided by LIRNEasia in a research article (2009) titled “Banded Forbearance: A New Approach to Price Regulation” compiled by LIRNEasia Chair Prof.
Links
User Login
Themes
Social
Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feed
Contact
12, Balcombe Place, Colombo 08
Sri Lanka
+94 (0)11 267 1160
+94 (0)11 267 5212
info [at] lirneasia [dot] net
Copyright © 2024 LIRNEasia
a regional ICT policy and regulation think tank active across the Asia Pacific