An external evaluation of the Pan Asian Networking program under which LIRNEasia was funded since 2006 has just been published on the IDRC website. There are many references to LIRNEasia, one of the larger projects funded by PAN, but I found the para below the most intriguing:
Influence on telecommunications policy reform has been one of the strongest areas of the program’s outcomes, at least in terms of explicit causality, specifically from the work of LIRNEasia. According to many informants, however, LIRNEasia, is a special case given the organizational culture, the numbers of people devoted to working almost exclusively on policy issues, the specific policy arena in which they work, and the strong personality at the center of the group. While LIRNEasia successes are notable, the external review panel urges the program not to set LIRNEasia as a standard for outcomes, since their achievements would be difficult to replicate elsewhere.
The quotation has been taken from the Findings Brief, prepared by the IDRC Evaluation Unit, though the same sentiments are also found in the External Review Report.
2 Comments
Sujata
At LIRNEAsia we have always managed to see action or research ideas in all types of situations. This is no different. I see some interesting possibilities for action research by IDRC or anybody interested.
Take the four reasons cited by the panel to conclude that the LIRNEAsia cannot be replicated. I see in those a valuable distillation of observations that deserves what I call Strong Inferencing – i.e. not go for the first inference that comes to mind but consider all possible inferences. for example:.
ALTERNATIVE INFERENCE:
“We can find and nurture such a combination of attributes through a new funding mechanism”
CRUCIAL EXPERIMENT:
An open-ended call for proposals for think tanks requiring (1) a focus on a policy arena with a higher possibility of impact (2) a strong leader with credibility in the arena (3) an action plan to develop a team of policy intellectuals within a conducive organizational culture ”
LIRNEasia with its regional experience in developing capacity can even be asked to help IDRC in carrying out the crucial experiment!
Guru Sidero
I think you should see the glass half filled.
Many think policy changes are about policy briefs with fancy graphs and flashy presentations that makes Accenture cry. These fools don’t achieve anything in real life. All such policy briefs are duly filed (in a folder or a computer server) and forgotten in time.
Few think policy changes are about acting smart at the right moment, and hitting hard. They make their mark.
While fancy graphs and flashy presentations can be replicated, the real efforts cannot. They need distinctive skills. Such skills are extremely rare and can never be replicated.
You are lucky to have evaluators who not only recognise your true strengths but also make a great compliment (perhaps unintentionally) by rightly admitting their irreplicability. That is something I would like to hear from my own evaluators.
LIRNEasia is hiring: Senior Researcher
LIRNEasia is looking for an experienced individual to fill the position of Senior Researcher. The full job description is available here.
LIRNEasia at IGF Sri Lanka 2024: Bridging the digital divide
The Internet Governance Forum Sri Lanka (IGF Sri Lanka) 2024 took place in Colombo in December 2024, marking a significant step in Sri Lanka’s journey toward inclusive and collaborative Internet governance. Hosted by the Lanka School of Internet Governance (LKSIG), this two-day event brought together policymakers, industry leaders, civil society, academics, and the technical community to discuss critical aspects of Internet policy, accessibility, and governance.
2025 – Wishing a year of impact!
In 2024, we proudly celebrated 20 years of impactful work— advancing research, catalyzing policy change, and improving lives across Asia and the Pacific through innovative solutions and technology. Our journey continues as we embrace new challenges and opportunities to create even greater impact.
Links
User Login
Themes
Social
Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feed
Contact
12, Balcombe Place, Colombo 08
Sri Lanka
+94 (0)11 267 1160
+94 (0)11 267 5212
info [at] lirneasia [dot] net
Copyright © 2025 LIRNEasia
a regional ICT policy and regulation think tank active across the Asia Pacific