Auction design is hot. The Economist reports on 4G auction design in the UK:
The government will want to squeeze as much revenue as it can from the sell-off, but it must also preserve competition in a consolidating industry. The recent merger of Orange and T-Mobile has left Britain with four mobile-phone operators: Everything Everywhere (the imperious name for the newly merged company), Vodafone, O2 and Three. That is a healthy number compared with some countries, such as America, where AT&T’s proposed acquisition of T-Mobile USA would create what some regard as, in effect, a duopoly. But Three warns that it would struggle in an unrestrained bidding war with its larger rivals for the new spectrum. Without 4G services, it might be forced out of the market, cutting the number of operators to three.
Ed Richards, head of Ofcom, the telecommunications regulator, appears to share this concern. The draft auction rules surprised many in the industry by explicitly aiming to preserve four providers. Ofcom plans to do this by capping how much spectrum any one company can buy, and by forcing the auction to be repeated if four separate bids are not successful.
2 Comments
Payal Malik
Mergers and Acquisitions if vetted properly by a competition authority for the effect on competition should not be scoffed at. M&As are the lifeblood of healthy competition. The regulators in their ex-ante role of fostering competition also decide on the minimum number of players. Artificial scarcity of spectrum can act as a spoiler and the adverse outcome will be that the operators do not get the minimum efficient scale of spectrum. But that does not mean give out spectrum on the basis of a “beauty contest”. Good auction designs can take care of competition and transparency.
However, analysts who talk about competition in terms of the survival of the small players correlate the number of players to competition. Competition is what emerges from the market and M&As are a part of the package. Who best can decide whether after a minimum has been prescribed and after M&As have carefully looked at the impact on competition what should be the optimal number of operators? No one else but the market. So to cry for the small operators, is just a legacy of the socialist thinking!
After all these are oligopolistic industries with huge investment requirements, so is steel, and cannot be operated from the backyards. Going back to Schumpeter, these industry structures are hot beds of innovation and have from our recent experiences served the consumer well!
The cries to protect the small operators form the “ills” of auction may be well meaning for these operators but not for the million consumers! Some gainers and some losers is the name of the game, as far as the gainers outstrip the losers we are doing fine!
Payal Malik
So while, auctions if designed properly can achieve competition as well as transparency for a given amount of available spectrum, and the above comment should also be seen as a reply to the earlier blog
http://lirneasia.net/2011/03/europe-repeats-mistakes-with-spectrum/
Consumer protection in telecommunication services
In a wide-ranging interview, the Director General of the Sri Lanka Telecom Regulatory Commission (TRC) explained the reasons for requiring mandatory registration of IMEI numbers from October 1, 2020, saying all commercial vendors of terminal devices had to be registered with the TRC and that the IMEIs of the devices they sold had to be registered as well. He stated that these actions were being taken to protect consumers.
Disability Innovation Pre-Accelerator Lab in India
The Disability Innovation Pre-Accelerator Lab which was held as a virtual event from 10th August to 26th August was successfully completed. LIRNEasia organized this event in collaboration with Vihara Innovations Network as part of our work on accessibility, PWDS (Persons With Disabilities) and use of ICT which is funded by the Ford Foundation.
Remote learning: Coverage is the necessary condition
The New York Times ran a poignant story about the travails of children unable to go to school in Indonesia. Today, about 13 million people across 12,500 remote villages have no access to the internet, said Setyanto Hantoro, president director of Telkomsel, the country’s largest telecommunications company, which is cooperating with the government to provide service in far-flung areas.
Links
User Login
Themes
Social
Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feed
Contact
12 Balcombe Place, Colombo 08
Sri Lanka
+94 (0)11 267 1160
+94 (0)11 267 5212
info [at] lirneasia [dot] net
Copyright © 2020 LIRNEasia
a regional ICT policy and regulation think tank active across the Asia Pacific