Nalaka Gunawardene asks good questions. So I paid attention when he tweeted:
Where does urban end & rural begin in #lka? Not silly admin demarcations, but in REAL terms? What decides: Tele-density? Purchasing power?
— Nalaka Gunawardene (@NalakaG) July 5, 2014
Based on the ongoing work using mobile transaction generated data (big data), we can give a good answer about areas that are predominantly residential, ans those that are mixed or predominantly commercial. But this will not mesh with the rural-urban divide. For example, it will show the densely populated Colombo North or Colombo’s inner city to be predominantly residential. It definitely is not rural.
Why does one need to know what is rural? Traditionally, it was because rural areas lacked in services; and needed extra attention. But Sri Lankan rural areas have never fit the pattern. We had post offices distributed across the country, at levels that matched those of Italy. We had rural dispensaries and hospitals.
I can see the value of identifying predominantly residential areas. Could someone answer the question as to why we need to identify rural?
Here is Nalaka’s response:
@samarajiva I want to see how true are persistent claims that 'rural' #lka is so info-deprived (thus justifying ICT4D projects & subsidies).
— Nalaka Gunawardene (@NalakaG) July 6, 2014
3 Comments
Delano Uduman
For purposes of Marketing & Social Research Surveys, the use of Sectors (Urban, Rural & Estate) was discontinued many years ago since this variable was no longer considered to be an efficient discriminator of local market segments. In it’s place we now use ‘SEC’ groups. The Socio Economic Classification (SEC) of Households is based on two variables – The Occupation of the Main Earner and the Highest Exam Passed by the Main Earner. The SEC as defined above yields five mutually exclusive and exhaustive sub-groups when applied to a population of households. Each sub-group represents a level of ‘life-style’ of the households in that group. Since ‘Consumption’ is driven by ‘Life-style’, the Socio Economic Classification of a sample of Households will provide a better segmentation of a prospective market with regard to both, Attitude & Behaviour.
Mr Nalaka Mendis should check out whether there is any significant ‘info-deprivation’ between the higher and lower Life-style groups.
For a detailed definition of SEC groups, please visit our web-site, http://www.srl.lk
Christoph Stork
Sri Lanka is very small and densely populated. The difference between urban and rural may thus be very small. The right distinction needs to be country specific and post offices are not really a good indicator on its own. Other options include:
1) Average size of land a households lives on = higher in rural areas.
2) Agricultural production distinguished by size. Presence of large scale would indicate rural areas.
3) Service density: secondary schools, universities, clinics, police stations, super markets, shopping centres, etc.
4) Income for a particular activity
5) Share of labour force employed in primary sector other than mining
The ideal distinction may combine several characteristics.
Rohan Samarajiva
In a technocratic, not political, approach we’d ask what the problem is and then evolve a remedy. For example, back in 2003, before mobile became cheap and spread to rural areas, we were thinking we needed to subsidize those areas. We did not use the government definition, which included the Kaduwela Pradeshiya Sabha (right up to Water’s Edge). Instead we calculated the population densities of each of the Divisional Secretariat Divisions. Those falling below a threshold were designated as eligible for subsidy. The cost of serving less densely populated areas is higher and revenues from them are lower. Therefore, our definition made sense.
In a smaller subsidy scheme that we ran from 1999, we simply stayed with the government definition. The cost of developing a different defensible definition was not justified by the size of the subsidy program.
Mr Uduman, above, has a different purpose, selling FMCGs. The definition he needs is different.
In political approaches, none of this matters. What matters is the message that is communicated. There is a strong sense of rural romanticism among even those who live in urban areas, so there are lots of political points to be scored by pandering to rural areas. I do not know whether this is still true, but between 1948 and 1977, the value of a vote of a rural resident was greater than that of an urban resident. That is it took more votes to elect an MP in Colombo than in Kahatagasdigiliya. In such weighted systems, it makes political sense to favor rural areas. Certain political parties do well in rural areas and not in urban. Therefore, they too emphasize rural subsidies and programs. A good technocrat will understand these factors and shape the rational argument accordingly.
#HomeBasedFlexiworkInCovid19 : Joint LIRNEasia, CPR and JustJobs Network panel at 2022 Internet Research Conference
Senior research managers Gayani Hurulle and Ayesha Zainudeen recently shared insights on the experience of women in India and Sri Lanka working remotely and flexibly during the pandemic at a jointly organised by LIRNEasia, the Centre for Policy Research (New Delhi) and the JustJobs Network at the 2022 Internet Research Conference (organised by the Centre for Internet and Society, CIS). LIRNEasia has been working with CPR and JJN over the last two and a half years on research on if and how digital platforms are empowering women with regards to work opportunities in India and Sri Lanka.
Cash transfers to the poor urgently needed; but who is poor in Sri Lanka?
The need for cash transfer to ease the inflationary burden faced by Sri Lankans has never been higher. While the monthly amounts paid by the Government are paltry, it will at least provide minor relief to those who need it the most.
LIRNEasia research on vaccine communications at 22nd ICA Conference
I recently participated in a panel discussion on “Health Communication: Risk & Strategies during COVID-19” at the International Communications Association (ICA) Conference (South Asia Regional Hub) on 29 May 2022. This session was also streamed at the main ICA Conference in Paris.
Links
User Login
Themes
Social
Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feed
Contact
15 1/2, Balcombe Place, Colombo 08
Sri Lanka
+94 (0)11 267 1160
+94 (0)11 267 5212
info [at] lirneasia [dot] net
Copyright © 2022 LIRNEasia
a regional ICT policy and regulation think tank active across the Asia Pacific