The headline suggests the focus is on the capture of regulatory agencies by retired IAS officers. But it is more, a wide-ranging discourse on problems of regulatory governance. It is a pity that the arguments are harmed by sloppy blame attribution: how can TRAI be blamed for spectrum auctions, when the article itself recognizes that is in the province of the Department of Telecommunications?
So how do we reverse this capture of important decision-making bodies by the bureaucracy? In 2006, the Planning Commission published a report (Approach to Regulations: Issues and Options) with some suggestions. The report highlights the fact that there is no uniformity in thinking behind setting up independent regulators. It points to the fact that many of them differ in terms of the extent of powers, tenure of members, selection procedures, and more. The petroleum regulator, for instance, can issue licences but has no say over tariffs. CERC fixes tariffs and issues licences, while trai has only recommendatory powers. To fix these things, it suggests setting up a regulatory affairs department in the Ministry of Personnel and having a minister for regulatory affairs. The idea was to bring in some oversight.
Read more at: http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/revenge-of-the-babus-liberalisation-expanded-power-of-bureaucracy/1/312039.html
3 Comments
Abu Saeed Khan
Appointing Raghuram Rajan as the Governor of India’s central bank is a good example of meritocracy dwarfing the bureaucracy. The writer has referred to FCC commissioners’ appointment but ignored the hiring of Rajan. There is no scarcity of equivalents like Rajan in other sectors. Lawmakers in the world’s largest democracy, however, lacks moral authority to govern the bureaucrats.
“After the last general election, 162 of the 543 members of the Lok Sabha, the lower house, had criminal cases against them, including charges of rape, murder and kidnapping, according to civil rights watchdogs,” wrote the Financial Times on September 27, 2013. Indian bureaucrats fully exploit the lawmakers’ such abysmal image and fortify their position. Pity!
Rohan Samarajiva
But how does Bangladesh make appointments to the BTRC and the energy regulatory agency? Perhaps the systems are superior to those in India?
Abu Saeed Khan
The situation is worse in Bangladesh. We have developed a veracious appetite for everything wrong in India and Pakistan. It has been a tug-of-war between the civil and military bureaucracy in telecom regulatory commission. Civil servants control the energy regulator. Disgraced military dictator Ershad had hijacked the civil aviation authority and gave it to air force. No democratic government, since deposing Ershad in 1990, has changed it. The list is long, very long…..
The Many Approaches to Caring in Ageing Societies of South and Southeast Asia
As societies grow older, their needs too evolve, with greater pressure on care systems being widely acknowledged as a critical issue. Broadly, care work involves supporting the physical, mental and development needs of people either directly or indirectly, while a care system refers to its overall organization (UN, 2024).
FutureWORKS Asia Network Meeting 2026: Brings Researchers Together in Bangkok
From 9–12 June 2026, FutureWORKS Asia convened its annual Network Meeting in Bangkok, Thailand, bringing together researchers from both cycles of funded projects for the first time. While Cycle 1 teams were nearing the completion of their research and beginning to translate their findings into policy recommendations, Cycle 2 teams were in the early stages of their research.
Expert Consultation on the CHIPS Digital Economy Assessment for Sri Lanka
On 17 July 2026, GovTech Sri Lanka and the Ministry of Digital Economy (MoDE), together with LIRNEasia, organized an Expert Consultation on the CHIPS Digital Economy Assessment for Sri Lanka. The session was conducted with funding support from the Asian Development Bank (ADB).
Links
User Login
Themes
Social
Twitter
Facebook
RSS Feed
Contact
9A 1/1, Balcombe Place
Colombo 08
Sri Lanka
+94 (0)11 267 1160
+94 (0)11 267 5212
info [at] lirneasia [dot] net
Copyright © 2026 LIRNEasia
a regional ICT policy and regulation think tank active across the Asia Pacific